Application of Game Theory, In Order to Conciliate Urmia Lake Basin Water Conflict

Authors

1 Ph. D student of Water Resources Engineering, Dept. of Water Engineering, Faculty of Agriculture, University of Urmia, Urmia, Iran.

2 Prof. Dept. of Water Engineering, Faculty of Agriculture, University of Urmia, Urmia, Iran.

Abstract

Several researches have been performed to investigate reasons of Urmia Lake dry out and solutions to stop Lake Shrinkage. In this research, by means of game theory and establishing five different scenarios, the Urmia Lake Conflict, has been discussed. Therefore, income of agriculture sector and water which is discharged to lake, are introduced as two players. In this non-cooperative game, the basin consumers sector was not allowed to consume more than 100% of Natural Renewable Water Resources and at least 3.5 billion cubic meters of water was allocated to Lake. Moreover, another hypothesis was that Agricultural Income should not be less than current amount. Based on above limitations, compared to other scenarios, the 4th scenario, in which, irrigated cropping pattern was completely prohibited and all orchards were irrigated using drip irrigation, presented the most desirable results. In the equilibrium, which was located at 4th scenario, Agricultural, Domestic and Industry sectors, consumed 26.78% of natural renewable water and 4235 mcm of water was allocated to Lake. Moreover, the agricultural income in this equilibrium was increased by 19% compared to current situation. At the equilibrium, as a consequence of crop irrigation prohibition, current costs diminished and therefore it might be in interest of farmers more than other scenarios.

Keywords

References

Abdoli GH, 2007. Game theory and its applications. Jahad Daneshgahi Publishing Organization. Tehran. (In Persian)
Abrishamchi A, Danesh-Yazdi M and Tajrishy M, 2011. Conflict resolution of water resources allocations using game theoretic approach: the case of Orumieh river basin in Iran. AWRA summer specialty conference. June 27 – 29. Snowbird, Utah, USA.
Abrishamchi A, Danesh-Yazdi M and Tajrishy M, 2014. Conflict resolution of water resources allocations using the game theoretic approach: the case of Orumieh river basin. Journal of Water and Wastewater. 25(2): 48-57. (In Persian with English abstract)
Afsari A, Haji Naseri S, Fazeli M and Firahi D, 2018. A sociological examination of water governance in lake urmia crisis: grounded theory model. Strategic Studies of Public Policy. 7(25): 53-72.
Anonymous, 1994. Studies of the second preliminary phase of the project: Shahid Kalantari Highway, located in Urmia Lake. Ministry of Roads and Transportation. Volume 16. (In Persian)
Anonymous, 2002. Urmia Lake environmental management project. Ministry of Jihad Agriculture: Deputy of Water and Soil, Iran. (In Persian)
Anonymous, 2006. Game Theory. Http: //plato.stanford.Edu/entries/game-theory.
Anonymous, 2010. Comprehensive management program of Urmia Lake catchment area. Protection Plan for Wetlands in Iran, Iran. (In Persian)
Anonymous, 2013. List of exploited dams of Urmia main catchment area, Deputy of Design and Development: Water Resources Development Plans Office, Iran. (In Persian)
Anonymous, 2015. Expert Working Group Report on Urmia Lake Drying, Iran. (In Persian)
Anonymous, 2015. Investigation and analysis of economic and social situation of Urmia Lake catchment area. Third edition, Iran. (In Persian with English abstract)
Anonymous, 2015. Report of the Social and Cultural Committee of Urmia Lake, causes of drought and possible threats. Vol.1. (In Persian)
Banitalebi Dehkordi M and Rezaie H, 2019. Evaluation of renewable water resources of Urmia Lake Basin using GLEAM. Iran Water Resources Research. 15(3): 144-154. (In Persian with English abstract)
Djafarov T, 2011. Water transfer of Aras River to Lake Urmia is discussed between Iran and Azerbaijan. Trend News Agency, 26 December 2011.
Eimanifar A and Mohebbi F, 2007. Urmia Lake (Northwest Iran): a brief review. Saline Systems. 3(5): 1-18.
Golabian H, 2010. Urumia Lake: hydro-ecological stabilization and permanence macro-engineering seawater in unique environments. Pp.65–397, pringer-Verlag, Berlin.
Hardin G, 1968. The tragedy of the commons. Science. 162(3859): 1243-1248.
Hardin G, 1993. Living Within Limits. Oxford University Press. UK.
Hassanzadeh E, Zarghami M and Hassanzadeh Y, 2012. Determining the main factors in declining the Urmia Lake level by using system dynamics modeling. Water Resources Management. 26(1): 129–145.
Jalili Kamjoo SP and Khosh Akhlagh R, 2016. Using the game theory in optimal allocation of water in Zayandehrud. Iranian Journal of Applied Economic Studies. 5(18): 53-80. (In Persian with English abstract)
Just R and Netanyahu S, 1998. International water resource conflicts: Experience and potential. Natural Resource Management and Policy 11: 1-26.
Lallana C and Marcuello C, 2016. Indicator Fact Sheet (WQ2): Water use by Sectors. European Environment Agency, Copenhagen.
Li B, Tan G and Chen G, 2016. Generalized uncooperative planar game theory model for water distribution in transboundary rivers. Water Resources Management. 30(1): 225-241.
Loaiciga HA, 2004. Analytic game theoretic approach to ground-water extraction. Journal of Hydrology. 297(1-4): 22-33.
Madani K and Dinar A, 2012b. non-cooperative institutions for sustainable common pool resource management: application to groundwater. Ecological Economics 1(74): 34–45.
Madani K and Dinar A, 2012a. Cooperative institutions for sustainable common pool resource management: application to groundwater. Water Resources Research. 48(9): 1–30.
Madani K and Hipel K, 2011. Non-cooperative stability definitions for strategic analysis of generic water resources conflicts. Water Resources Management. 25(8): 1949–1977.
Madani K and Lund J, 2012. California's Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta conflict: from cooperation to chicken. ASCE Journal of Water Resources Planning and Management. 138(2): 90-99.
Madani K, 2010. Game theory and water resources. Journal of Hydrology. 381(3-4): 225-238.
Mazandaranizadeh H, Ghaheri A and Abdoli A, 2009. Sustainable exploitation model of groundwater aquifer shared between urban and agricultural operators using game theory. Agricultural Economics and Development, 17(68): 77-102. (In Persian with English abstract)
Mohammadpour M and Bagheri A, 2017. Common pool water resources management considering a regulator interference: A game theory approach to derive managerial policies for Urmia Lake, Iran. Lakes & Reservoirs Research & Management. 22(1): 85-94.
Oftadeh E, Shourian M and Saghafian B, 2017. An ultimatum game theory-based approach for basin scale water allocation conflict resolution. Water Resources Management. 31(13): 4293-4308.
Omidvar M, Honar T, Nikoo MR and Sepaskhah AR, 2016. Developing a fuzzy crop pattern and water allocation optimization model based on cooperative game theory: a case study, Ordibehesht canal at the Doroodzan irrigation network, northwest of Fars province in Iran. Journal of Water and Soil Sciences-Isfahan University of Technology. 20(76): 1-13. (In Persian with English abstract)
Ostrom E, 2010. Beyond markets and states: polycentric governance of complex economic systems. American Economic Review. 100(3): 641-672.
Ostrom E, Gardner R and Walker J, 1994. Rules, Games and Common-Pool Resources. University of Michigan Press.
Poundstone W, 1992. Prisoner’s Dilemma: John von Neuman, Game Theory, and the Puzzle of the Bomb, Anchor.
Qandahari A, Alavi Moghaddam M and Omranian Khorasani H, 2016. Water resources management in Harirood catchment based on game theory. Water and Sustainable Development. 3(1): 115-121. (In Persian with English abstract)
Safaei A and Malek Mohammadi B, 2014. Game theory guidelines for sustainable governance of common water resources (case study: Urmia Lake water conflict). Journal of Environmental Science. 40(1): 121-138. (In Persian with English abstract)
Zarghami M and Ehsani I, 2011. Evaluation of different group multi-criteria decision-making methods in selection of water transfer projects to Urmia Lake Basin. Iranian Water Resources Research. 7(2):1-14. (In Persian with English abstract)
Zarghami M and Safari N, 2013. Optimum water allocation for agricultural section of Zarrinehrud River by non-symmetric Nash modeling. Iranian Journal of Agricultural Economics. 7(2): 107-125. (In Persian with English abstract)
Water and Soil Science
Volume 32, Issue 4
December 2022
Pages 147-168

Files

Share

How to cite

Statistics